Arthur x Sue

I didn't mean anything wrong, okay?




I got this idea from that other CS spritecomic. Like, they didn't really mention Sue knowing Arthur in-game, right? But then, Sue did seem to have been there long enough to know even everything inside the village.





Thread ends here.

 

Sue wasn't on the island until after Arthur died.

 

Makes me wonder due to the speculation that the Doctor's minions killed Arthur, since I've heard the theories that Arthur killed Miakid.
Sue and her family, Prof. Booster, and the Doctor went to the Island at the same time, I thought.

 

So did they make an acquaintance of each other before they went to the island or only after?

 

They never met, so neither.

 

Err..... he wanted Sue.

 

No he didn't. He could very well want someone he never met.

 

Andwhy?

 

Eh. Pointless thread though. Hopefully soon it'll be locked.
Toroko basically hid her there in Arthur's house. Arthur never met Sue.
So, yeah.

 

Arthur was probably killed before Sue was turned into a mimiga. Also, once Sue was a mimiga she was likely in the plantation until she escaped somehow.

 

Arthur was probably killed before Sue was turned into a mimiga. Also, once Sue was a mimiga she was likely in the plantation until she escaped somehow.

Yeah. Makes more sense.

 

I'm sure it's mentioned in-game that Arthur was killed by Doctor's goons, which could be only after the humans arrived at the Island. There could have only been a short time between Sue's arrival at the Village and Arthur's death. The problem is, which happened first?

 

Which reverts back to the topic of Plotholes and such that we don't know.

 

Which reverts back to the topic of Plotholes and such that we don't know.

Which is why this thread is in "Cave Story Theories", as in "we don't know anything about it, so we make up stuff about it and post it on an online forum".

 

Which is why this thread is in "Cave Story Theories", as in "we don't know anything about it, so we make up stuff about it and post it on an online forum".

This.

We just throw ideas at the wall until some stick.

 

*Shrugs* Just stating it's becoming like the other topic. That's all.
Damn man, lighten up.

 

You mean the Jake thread. It's like that because it's a Jake thread.




Ok maybe it's just the comic, but maybe he met her while facing the Doctor as well. But where did Sue come from anyway, and again, the Doctor wanted Sue. Quite peculiar there, underline the quite.

 

But where did Sue come from anyway, and again, the Doctor wanted Sue. Quite peculiar there, underline the quite.

He wanted sue because he knew sue would be trying to work against him. And thus wanted to keep an eye on her.:eek:

 

He wanted sue because he knew sue would be trying to work against him. And thus wanted to keep an eye on her.:eek:

Or just to get rid of the little brat.

 

Maybe The Doctor hates little kids.