128 replies to this topic

[Wild Desu]

It's special because all the characters have disabilities (no pun intended). I guess that's its unique element. I think the creators didn't wanna settle for a typical dating sim, and decided to add a twist to it.

And hey, the only other VN I've played is Saya no Uta, but I can still say I enjoy the game, right? It may be pretty overrated now but still. Doesn't make it a bad game.

But of course, fanbases give people bad impressions. Guess you could say the same things about ponies and homestuck

Edited by Wild Desu, 06 February 2012 - 05:21 AM.

[Captain Fabulous]

Well as a matter of fact, Desu, the creators set out with the six main characters in mind. That was their inspiration.

As for you, GIR, I don't see why one has to play multiple visual novels to declare that Katawa Shoujo is a good read. I enjoyed it, why does my enjoyment have to be qualified by comparing it to other works?

Katawa Shoujo is a collection of stories about five (six?) girls and some dumbass who falls in love with whichever girl you choose. All of the stories are heartwarming and emotional or some shit. One chick, for example, has burns all over her body and she's all shy and you, of course, are like "AWWWWW" and it's a fucking masterpiece.

If I can like this over-hyped pile of melodramatic weeaboo chow enough to publicly defend it, then I would say it's definitely worth trying because I'm the last person I thought would enjoy it.

[Yakkers]

Hmm.
I think I'll just stick to Morenatsu.

Edited by Yakkers, 06 February 2012 - 05:38 AM.

[Captain Fabulous]

I googled that, and was disappointed to find that it's not exactly my cup of tea.
Well, I guess if it has absolutely stellar writing I could give it a look.

[Wild Desu]

I love how you always post in such a cynical and scathing way, just to hide how much of a softie you are. Trying to keep up appearances as the forum asshole.


Anyway...

[JiNXeD]

Yeah I've played read it. Finished all campaigns. I didn't find it very emotionally touching or anything though.
I'd have to say that Lilly is my favourite character. Still, it's a great visual novel and a masterpiece.

[cultr1]

JiNXeD you have no soul.

Fine GIR, afraid of hype?
How about this:
I like this game a bunch, it isn't my style of game at all, but it was good enough to keep me playing for multiple arcs. You should try it.

Yakkers, I don't care if you play it or not, but keep in mind that people recommend things to you for a reason: because they think you'd like it. If you choose to disregard that, that's fine, but remember that people aren't trying to get you to play some horrible visual novel that's a waste of time, we all genuinely enjoyed it.
So what I'm saying is: I really care if you play this or not.

Edited by cultr1, 06 February 2012 - 03:02 PM.

[GIRakaCHEEZER]

This is my favorite thing ever, it's getting more hype than other VNs because it's well written, has amazingly deep characters, touching storylines, great music, and it doesn't cost you a goddamn penny. Go playing this game right now, it'll be one of the best things you'll ever do.

See this is another issue I have. You're so enthusiastic about this game that it scares me. It's giving me a bit of Hype Aversion, especially now hearing that /v/ is all over it.

Regardless I've broken down and started playing this thing. I'll have more to say once I finish.

[DoubleThink]

Jesus H. Christ does this thread have to appear on every forum I'm on

I've seen /v/ jerking off over this game for month now. Can somebody tell me what it has that makes it so special compared to other VN's? Is it some big joke or something?

It was made by 4chan and therefore gets disproportionate levels of attention regardless of how samey it is

[cultr1]

Because a lot of people like it...?
You're right GIR, I think I'll tone it down a bit. Do you think you could edit your quote though? Wouldn't be much use in changing it if everyone just saw your post next.

And you're completely right, DoubleThink! This game got unreal amounts of hype with the whole "made by 4chan" bit. That always made me laugh, though. 22 guys who met on 4chan and made this game doesn't really constitute as "made by 4chan" in my books, but I suppose the hype is good.
And yeah, this game would still receive a possibly too good reception based on that, even if it were samey piece of crap. Fortunately, I couldn't care less who made it, and I really did enjoy this game because it broke the mold of Visual Novels, which I've always had aversion to.

If you don't play it, that's your business, but I think that maybe getting out of your shell and trying something your friends like would result in you enjoying yourself :3
I mean, what's the worst that could happen? You could play a game for an hour, hate it, uninstall it, and sleep peacefully with the certainty that you're not missing out. I'd say that's a pretty fair deal

Edited by cultr1, 06 February 2012 - 03:30 PM.